Tom, Adam, and Bryan - 3 of the hottest straight guys I've ever set eyes on!

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys 32:17

Dylan Plows Brian / Dylan & Craig

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys • Twink

Twink Amateur

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys 0:39

Bryan & Ck Now in 4K

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys • Twink

Twink Amateur

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys 9:49

Before ASG started, was a pilot video we shot and it's hot! now in 4k, remastered 2022!

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys • Amateur

Amateur Big Cock

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys 41:13

Sean & Bryan plus Sean & Vince in 2K!

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys • Amateur

Amateur Bear

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys 12:40

Tom after the party!! 4K!

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys • Amateur

Amateur Bear

The Great Canadian Male 1:14:23

Straight Boys With Toys 2

The Great Canadian Male • Twink

Twink Amateur

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys 23:29

Jackson, Guzzo, & Rob Remastered in 2K!

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys • Amateur

Amateur Blowjob

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys 13:51

James & Diesel in HD!

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys • Amateur

Amateur Blowjob

Tomas Styl 6:01

I Put Her in the University Bathroom so She Can Give Me a Great Blowjob She's Such a Bitch

Tomas Styl • Twink

Twink Amateur

The Great Canadian Male 44:58

Fuck the Boss 13

The Great Canadian Male • Man

Man Twink

Mr hairy gardener 14:15

I Deep-throat My Hubby's Huge Cock Then Bust a Thick, Creamy Load

Mr hairy gardener • Amateur

Amateur Big Cock

Hung str8 guys 0:39

Hung Str8 Enjoy Afternoon Head

Hung str8 guys • Amateur

Amateur Big Cock